Two of my current listings make a good comparison. One is a fully remodeled home in Stilwell. The other is a small house in Westville that was built in 2025. They are very different homes, and the questions you should ask about each are not the same.
The remodel: 226 E Cedar St, Stilwell
This one is listed at $210,000. It has 4 bedrooms, 2 baths and 1,716 square feet on 0.16 acre. The inside was redone: vaulted ceilings, a black brick fireplace, and a new kitchen with an island and stainless appliances. There is a front deck and a big gravel drive.
With a remodel, the finishes are new but the bones are not. The walls, the foundation and the lines behind the walls came with the house. So I tell buyers to ask what was replaced and what was only covered up. Ask who did the work, whether it was permitted, and whether there are receipts. A good inspection matters more here than almost anywhere.
The new build: 1415 S Locust Ave, Westville
This one is listed at $150,000. It has 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths and 810 square feet on 0.15 acre, and it was built in 2025. It has granite counters, custom cabinets, three mini-split units for heating and cooling, a covered carport, and a slab out back that is ready for a shop. City utilities are connected.
A newer house usually means fewer surprises in the first few years. The tradeoff is size. At 810 square feet, you are choosing a smaller footprint. Ask what is covered by any builder warranty, how the mini-splits are serviced, and what you are allowed to build on that back slab.
How I help you decide
- Start with your monthly number. Price is only part of it. Ask about insurance, utilities and upkeep for each house.
- List what you cannot give up. Bedrooms, a shop, a big yard, a short drive to work. The house that checks those boxes wins.
- Get the inspection either way. New does not mean perfect, and remodeled does not mean sound.
- Ask about the lot. Utilities, fencing, drainage and what you can add later all change the value to you.
Neither house is the better choice for everyone. They are different tools for different plans. If you want to walk through either one, or see what else is out there in this price range, I will give you my honest, unbiased opinion.
I'm Dayna Hume with Century 21 Wright Real Estate. Text me at 918-696-9405.
Questions about your own situation? Text or call me at 918-696-9405.